Robin Tunney (Sarah Bailey)

Robin Tunney played Sarah, the new girl in school who falls in with a coven of wannabe witches.

Tunney was fresh off her troubled, rebellious turn in Empire Records (1995), so taking up the dark arts in The Craft was the logical next step. Not long afterward, she was cast in the biblical Arnold Schwarzenegger horror film End of Days (1999) as no less than the chosen mother of Satan's child. Her genre forays continued with the outer-space horror flick Supernova (2000) and the survival thriller Vertical Limit (2000) before she carved out a niche on the indie circuit, including Alan Rudolph’s acclaimed The Secret Lives of Dentists (2002).

The actress played famed socialite Leonore Lemmon, ex-fiancee of the tragic George Reeves (Ben Affleck), in Hollywoodland (2006), and found a home on the small screen around that time, too. She was a key player in season 1 of Prison Break (2005–2006) and then landed the role of Teresa Lisbon on The Mentalist (2008–2015). Recently, she was seen in the Apple TV+ drama Dear Edward (2023).

Tunney was married to filmmaker Bob Gosse from 1997 to 2006. She's been engaged to Nicky Marmet, with whom she shares two children, since 2012.

02 of 07

Spanish actress Assumpta Serna appeared as Lirio Santana, the owner of an occult store.

Lirio offers Sarah advice on witchcraft and gives her a book titled "Beginner's Guide to the Craft." After the coven turns on Sarah, she goes to Lirio for help.

Lirio shows Sarah her sanctuary in the back of her store and tries to teach her to invoke Manon, which would strip the other witches of her power. However, before she can, Sarah is frightened away by a false vision of the shop exploding.

Christine Taylor (Laura Lizzie)

Christine Taylor had an early career heel turn as Laura, a racist high school student who gets punished for harassing Rochelle.

After landing her big break on Nickelodeon’s Hey Dude (1989–1991), Taylor brought a classic sitcom character to the silver screen as Marcia in The Brady Bunch Movie (1995) parody and its sequel. She’s been a regular in comedy ever since, appearing in many of her husband Ben Stiller’s films — including Zoolander (2001), Dodgeball (2004), and Tropic Thunder (2008) — as well as Adam Sandler’s rom-com The Wedding Singer (1998).

Taylor and Stiller married in 2000 and share a daughter, Ella, and a son, Quinlin. The couple separated in 2017 but reconciled during the COVID-19 lockdown in 2020.

07 of 07

Fairuza Balk starred as Nancy Downs, the movie's eventual antagonist.

Following her role in "The Craft," Balk landed the role of Sapphire in another cult classic, "Almost Famous," starring Kate Hudson. She was nominated for a Screen Actors Guild Award for outstanding performance by a cast in a motion picture in 2000.

Balk has also done voice work for a number of TV shows and documentaries, including "Family Guy" and "Justice League."